In the old covenant, the choice was about law. Covenant law. Keep it or not. It gave no one eternal life or changed a heart or conscience. It did nothing to change the sin nature of man. In the new, because of Jesus defeating, (removing the condemning power of sin) this enemy by meeting its just punishment for the one who would believe, the choice to be made is not one of law, but one of faith. And no one is denying that it is a choice. What they are saying is, that since something in man's nature has to change towards God (the natural enmity) it is not something man can willingly do. He can't will a different nature. He can't will His enmity towards God to go away. Man is like this because He was born in Adam. Therefore he has to be reborn in Christ, something only God can do, for man cannot will a new birth into existence simply by choosing to. It is done in a person by the Holy Spirit, who is an entity, not a power or force, though He has power. To say that man has to will a new birth before the spirit (as you call Him) will give it to him, makes no sense at all. Being born in Christ is just as real and tangible as being born in Adam.
In the new covenant, the choice is about faith [belief/trust] in Jesus being the Messiah or not. In the new covenant, our desires change wherein we abhor evil (which I am sure applied to many OT believers also). What changed in man was a "new creation in Christ" but it did not change the sin nature inherently in us or else there wouldn't be admonitions in the new covenant to put to death the deeds of the flesh [
Rom. 8:13], be not conformed to this world but be transformed by the renewing of your mind [
Rom.12:2], put off your old self [
Eph. 4:22;
Col. 3:9] and put on the new self [
Eph. 4:24;
Col. 3:10]; all something we make the choice to do.
I agree that the new birth is something only God, aka the Holy Spirit, does [not man willing a new birth] - Salvation is dependent upon one's belief [faith] in God's Son. They relate to each other - How do we obtain eternal life - entrance into the Kingdom of God? By being born again of the Spirit; aka whosoever believes in God's Son receives eternal life - this goes hand in hand.
That is moving the subject off target.
It was in direct response to what you had said.
You have the cart before the horse from a logical view.
You have the cart before the horse from a logical view.
How does one obtain eternal life aka enter the Kingdom of God? by being born again of the Spirit through faith/belief that Jesus is the Messiah,
through whom we obtain eternal salvation in the kingdom of God.
For by grace you have been saved through faith [belief in Jesus as the Messiah]. This is not of your own doing [the new birth, aka salvation]; it is the gift of God. . . . . The wages of sin is death, but the gift of God is eternal life
through Jesus Christ our Lord.
But then you also deny the deity of Christ and the Holy Spirit.
That is moving the subject off target.